Whittier College Diversity Scam Applied to Law School Backfires

In Whittier College v. American Bar Association, U. S. District Court, Central District of California, Case No. CV 07-1817 PA (FMOx), Whittier's request for orders to prevent the ABA from revoking Whittier Law School's accreditation, to enjoin the ABA from extending Whittier's probation, to revoke the ongoing 2005
two-year probation determination re Whittier Law School, and, most disturbing, to cause the ABA "to delete all references to Whittier's probationary status from all ABA websites and publications," were all denied by U. S. District Judge Percy Anderson on May 7, 2007.

Whittier College's diversity scam applied from the Whittier campus to the Whittier Law School may be the scam's undoing. While bachelor degree graduates from Whittier College don't have anything like the high school senior exit exam in California to test whether or not a student should be graduated, Whittier Law School graduates have a bar examination to test whether a graduate has been at least adequately educated in the law. Whittier can get away with graduating students who haven't really earned a college degree in the liberal arts, but Whittier hasn't found a way around the bar exam.

"...Whittier could lose its accreditation as soon as...August [2007]..." - Michael H. Rubenstein, Adjunct Professor at St. Johns and New York Law Schools, and Senior Counsel, New York State Unified Teachers.

Judge Anderson points out that Whittier has known all along that the bar exam pass rate is the standard by which all law schools are ultimately judged. While agreeing that diversifying the attorney pool is praiseworthy, the Court found that interest doesn't outweigh the facts that no one is well-served by inadequate standards, nor by censorship.

"Although being placed on probation has resulted in no small amount of difficulty for Whittier, the integrity of the ABA's accreditation process, and the interests of prospective students in being informed of the history of the poor first-time bar passage rate of Whittier's graduates, argues against the issuance of the injunctive relief Whittier seeks."

Whittier Law School has lost faculty members, and higher achieving students have transferred from Whittier to other law schools, in their own best interests - for which Whittieer College would project responsibility onto the ABA, rather than accept that responsibility for which it takes student families'money. Current Whittier College Law students report a previously absent sense of cutthroat every student for him- or herself on campus, reflecting Whittier's evident sense of desperation...

Whittier has taken action to try to raise its graduates' bar passage rate. The Whittier Law school has reduced enrollment and raised school standards, that is, Whittier has backed off at least in part from trying to apply its diversity scam to its Law School. While presenting itself as a champion of opportunity for minority students, Whittier is indeed exploiting such students. The ABA's expressed concerns about Whittier have not been limited to the Law School's below average bar passage rate, but have included, too, its high attrition and low career placement rates.

No doubt there are numerous graduates of Whittier Law School, as there are of Whittier College, who can or have distinguished themselves in their fields of action. This is not to insult Whittier graduates, it is rather to put a light to this dark institutional determination to exploit minorities for financial gain, in the name of diversity, which when said of domestic students gives support to an outdated view of society that retards integration, works against equality, and saddles dropout and graduate alike with crushing debt that was as easily avoided as avoiding enrolling at Whittier.

The obviousness of this scam should embarrass Whittier, but President Herzberger seems to have no problem at all suggesting the SAT, evidently like bar passage rates, is only one measure of success, that there are better ways of predicting success. Like asking a psychic, or your accountant maybe?

The Federal Court's not having any of that, and if minority students, especially Hispanics, who have to constitute 25% of Whittier students, half of whom have to be Hispanic and poor, for Whittier College to get loan money and federal Title V money out of you, do have the potential to succeed, then you should be able to do the math: Whittier wins, you lose. Did you notice how Hispanics are exactly 25% of the undergraduate student body? 25% is the absolute minimum necessary to receive the federal Title V monies.

If you dropout, you have a five figure debt on your back. If you graduate, you have the third highest debt of all liberal arts college grads in the United States on your back. How do you win? Having gone to or graduated from Whittier College?

Whittier College can use Maria Contreras-Sweet to dress up its Latino Graduation, but there is no separate and equal, there is only separate and unequal. Whittier College can dangle an honorary degree before Anthony Villaraigosa and get a hollow commencement key note speech, but Tony Villaraigosa didn't go to Whittier College. The young Tony Villaraigosa did exactly what this website recommends to all working poor students (See Diversity Scam link below), he went to a community college, East L. A. College, and then transferred to a subsidized university, UCLA, public ivy. No matter how dazzling the Tio Tomas acts may be, they do nothing toward bridging Whittier College's seemingly bottomless bottom line nor addressing serious questions about Whittier's ethics and academic standards. .

Anthony Villaraigosa was a fitting Whittier 2007 honorary degree recipient and commencement speaker in one respect: After being graduated with a Bachelor degree in History by UCLA, Tony Villaraigosa - kids, do not make this mistake - went to the unaccredited People's College of Law, and then failed, four times, to pass the California Bar exam. Villaraigosa is still unlicensed to practice law. Perhaps it was sympathy as well as vanity that persuaded Mayor Villaraigosa to swap yet another honorary degree for yet another commencement speech, but it's the students, not the school, who deserve the sympathy.

But then Anthony Villaraigosa's not known for either his character or being sympathetic, much less empathetic, nor for his scholarship. Villaraigosa's Whittier College 2007 Commencement keynote speech wrongly attributed the founding of the College to John Greenleaf Whittier, who as scholars know was never in the area. Villaraigosa was evidently too busy cheating on his wife, again, to check his facts. Villaraigosa's newest affair is with Mirthala Salinas, a tv news reporter and anchor who had the chutzpah (perhaps picked up in the condo complex of Jewish retirees where she resided and was visited by Tony alone bearing takeout and wine before the scandal broke and Salinas moved) to announce the impending divorce of Tony and Corina Villaraigosa on Telemundo's 6 o'clock news, the same news program airing not just one but two Public Service Announcements, featuring who else but Tony Villaraigosa, within its 30 prime time minutes. Salinas has been linked so to speak romantically with not only Villaraigosa, but also with Assembly Speaker Fabian Nunez, and former City Council President Alex Padilla, as the L. A. Weekly put it, "among others." Corina Villaraigosa, a local school teacher, has filed for divorce, again. The Los Angeles Times reports Villaraigosa has "two adult daughters born out of wedlock and his wife filed for divorce in 1994 over a separate affair for which he later publicly apologized." Perhaps Tony Villaraigosa was the perfect keynote speaker for Whittier College afterall. Again, kids, don't try this at home.

The most disturbing aspect of the dishonesty of Whittier College in Whittier v. ABA, though, is the effort by Whittier to have public information regarding its probation status, low bar exam passage rate, etc., deleted, kept from the public, from prospective students. The truth is that Whittier College wants to keep the truth hidden from you, blather about the light of learning and diversity, and collect the money. Meanwhile, Whittier's now being referred to as a fourth, not even third, tier school, and is one of only two law schools in the United States "currently on probation for failing to meet ABA standards," according to Res Gestae, the University of Michigan Law School paper, and the ABA, the U. S. District Court, Et Al.

Whether Whittier Law School is continued on probation, or loses its accreditation, or is normally accredited, Whittier College has revealed itself in its requests of the U. S. District Court: Whittier College believes it has to control the information you have access to about Whittier College. Whittier's point of view is so antithetical to the school's, any school's, mission, that institutional therapy is clearly in order. There are no demons lurking in the dark so formidable that a college must fear it more than snuffing out the light of learning, and if there are such horrific secrets, then better no school at all than a bad school. Whittier College refused to heed the Friends many years ago, Friends of conscience who birthed Whittier College. Will Whittier College heed the Court?

A federal court is telling Whittier Law School to make itself honestly successful, not to try to hide or rationalize failing to adequately educate its students. Whittier College should be doing better, being open, honestly trying to do the right things, for the stirrings of its own conscience. It shouldn't take a court to order a college, supposedly educating the professionals upon whom our lives may well depend, to be successful the old fashioned way, the way Whittier College should've been operating all along, or face probation or even loss of accreditation - that the public will know about. Poets, it looks as though it's wake up or a wake...

The National Law Journal
"Law School loses bid to shed probation status
Whittier decries ABA action, facing "ruin."
http://www.law.com/jsp/nlj/PubArticleNLJ.jsp?id=1179330294034

United States District Court
Central District of California
Whittier College v. American Bar Association
Case No. CV 07-1817 PA (FMOx) Civil Minutes
CLICK HERE

See how Whittier's Diversity Scam operates: CLICK HERE

See also

'Mayor reveals romantic link with TV newscaster' by Duke Helfand and Steve Hymon, Los Angeles Times, Wednesday, July 4, 2007, A-1

and

'Villaraigosa's Media Affair: Telemundo, where his girlfriend is an anchor, lavishes him with free airtime' by David Zahniser, L A Weekly, July 6-12, 2007, Pg. 32

For a primer on corruption in city politics, and the many affairs of and ethics violations by Anthony Villar-Raigosa (Villaraigosa is a blending as the mayor might describe it of Anthony Villar's and Corina Raigosa's names - will Corina want her name back now that she's finally divorcing Tony?), wade through this revelatory pooling of information by city hall insiders:

http://mayorsam.blogspot.com/2007/07/another-villaraigosa-affair.html

Mirthala Salinas wasn't remotely the first nor even the last of Tony Villaraigosa's affairs, many of which seem to involve ethics violations. Many agree that Villaraigosa's city administration is the most corrupt and corrupting since Mayor Shaw's in the 1930's, cleaned up only by rewriting Los Angeles' city charter. Yes, sadly, Tony Villaraigosa was the perfect Whittier College commencement keynote speaker.

Update: More recently, Mirthala Salinas was investigated by her employer, KVEA-TV Channel 52 / Telemundo / NBC Universal, and was found to have "violated Channel 52's ethical standards", and was suspended for two months without pay. At the end of Salinas' KVEA suspension, she was reassigned to Telemundo's Riverside bureau, far from Los Angeles' City Hall action. Salinas, however, failed to show up for her first day of work in the Inland Archipelago, which turned out therefore to be her last day of work for her employer the past 10 years. Even though Salinas' contract didn't end until December, her association with KVEA-TV was terminated on October 1, 2007.

Additionally, NBC Universal reprimanded Telemundo stations President Ibra Morales, KVEA General Manager Manuel Abud was removed from that position and is to be reassigned, and KVEA News Director Al Corral was suspended for two months without pay, all for their parts in violating the company's conflict of interest policies in relation to the Salinas-Villaraigosa scandal.

Meanwhile, Corina Villaraigosa NEE Raigosa, public school teacher and no longer long-suffering spouse of philanderer Tony Villar AKA Villaraigosa, has reemerged after filing for a divorce. Corina's first public appearance on her own was before the Girls Today, Women Tomorrow mentoring group, where Corina reminded us all that, "when you keep commitments to yourself, it's easier to keep commitments to others."
See http://flapsblog.com/?p=5327 for Villaraigosa scandal updates, including the political and economic consequences to the City of Los Angeles.

NEWS UPDATE

The American Bar Association has decided to continue Whittier Law School's probation status until 2009, when the school's performance will be reviewed, yet again, for compliance with ABA accreditation standards. A Whittier Law School attorney claimed earlier this year in federal court that Whittier is facing "ruin" because of its ABA-imposed probation status. Well, now we'll be able to see whether or not a Whittier College attorney has finally told the truth for a change... Either way, prospective students will not be kept in the dark about Whittier Law School's continued probation status.

Calls for Whittier Law School to publicly admit ABA extension of School's probation status to 2009 after whittiergate.com scoop: http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/adjunctprofs/2007/08/whittier-law-sc.html

Return to Main Page